The Importance of Effective Survivorship Care Plan Implementation

August 2018 Vol 9, No 8
Sarah A. Birken, PhD

Poor implementation of survivorship care plans (SCPs) ultimately limits the ability to determine whether they work, according to Sarah A. Birken, PhD, Assistant Professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

According to Dr Birken, the effectiveness of SCPs is determined, in part, by context and delivery. "We have a lot of evidence that the implementation of SCPs is not optimal, and if there is inconsistent implementation in randomized controlled trials, you can imagine what it looks like in practice," she said at the ASCO Cancer Survivorship Symposium. "We really need to understand the implementation of SCPs before we can understand whether they're effective."

Implementation refers to the proficiency and consistency with which any intervention, including the SCP, is used. Proficiency is the extent to which something is used as intended, whereas consistency refers to the extent to which the targeted population receives the intervention. According to Dr Birken, both are lacking when it comes to the delivery of SCPs.

In their research, Dr Birken and colleagues found that the "usual suspects" were determinants of poor SCP implementation: lack of time, money, and staff. "But we wanted to dig a little bit deeper to understand what was driving the use of SCPs," she said.

In addition to the usual suspects, the team found that cancer care providers' beliefs about the consequences of SCPs influenced their use, that is, "Is what I'm doing making a difference for anyone?" Having a leader who identified the use of SCPs as an organizational priority was also found to be a determinant.

The researchers worked alongside the Quality Oncology Practice Initiative (QOPI), an organization comprised of over 600 participating practices. QOPI practices collect and submit data regarding several quality benchmarks, of which SCP implementation is one. To identify strategies for the successful implementation of SCPs, Dr Birken and her team conducted interviews in 21 QOPI cancer programs with varying degrees of SCP implementation success.

"We found that high-performing cancer programs saw the requirements coming, and they started implementing early," she said. "They phased in their efforts to implement SCPs slowly and carefully and looked at requirements as an opportunity to improve their approach to survivorship care instead of simply checking a box to comply."

According to Dr Birken, high-performing cancer programs had someone in a leadership position who recognized the importance of the significant efforts involved in SCP implementation and stood behind them. They also appropriately delegated responsibility for SCP implementation and shielded the people in the organization who were not tasked with implementation, so that they could focus on their clinical and administrative duties.

"Very importantly, successful cancer programs ensured that this effort was not comprised of 1 highly motivated employee who, if they became sick or went on vacation, would result in the entire survivorship program falling apart," she added. They also found that auto-population of SCPs through electronic health records enhanced the influence of these tactics.

However, she warned that integrating these strategies into the appropriate workflow is critical for successful implementation. "Careful integration of these concepts is required in a way that makes sense for the particular context," she added. "Because taken out of context, these strategies might not work."

Overall, successful SCP implementation requires minimizing the burden on organizations and their employees and maximizing the benefit to survivors, caregivers, and primary care providers.

Related Articles
A Survivorship Workshop for Primary Care Providers
Genevieve Chaput, MD
August 2018 Vol 9, No 8
An educational survivorship workshop increased knowledge and confidence levels and demonstrated educational merit in a group of primary care providers (PCPs), according to research presented by Genevieve Chaput, MD, at the ASCO Cancer Survivorship Symposium.
The Importance of Survivorship: Focusing on the Health and Life of a Person with Cancer
Lillie D. Shockney, RN, BS, MAS, ONN-CG
July 2018 Vol 9, No 7
Promoting and enhancing survivorship are cornerstones of our mission as navigators. From community outreach efforts to improving quality of life, from managing efficiency throughout the cancer care continuum to implementing strategies to extend life, navigation efforts are primarily intended to improve the patient experience across the continuum of care.
Understanding Survivorship Care Plans: An Interview with Lillie D. Shockney, RN, BS, MAS, ONN-CG
July 2018 Vol 9, No 7
In 2005 the Institute of Medicine (IOM) issued a report recommending that every cancer patient receive an individualized survivorship care plan that includes guidelines for monitoring and maintaining their health. We discussed this topic with our Editor-in-Chief, Lillie D. Shockney, RN, BS, MAS, ONN-CG, to understand their purpose and contents, and the role of oncology professionals in their creation and dissemination.
Last modified: October 24, 2018

Subscribe to the Journal of Oncology Navigation & Survivorship®

To sign up for our print publication or e-newsletter, please enter your contact information below.

  • First Name *
    Last Name *
  • Please enter your mailing address.

    Address Line 2
    Zip Code