Shared Decision-Making in Multidisciplinary Teams: Challenges and Effective Practices for Navigators and Social Workers

November 2020 Vol 11, No 11
Christina Mangir, MS
Association of Community Cancer Centers
Leigh Boehmer, PharmD, BCOP
Association of Community Cancer Centers
Sandra E. Kurtin, PhD, ANP-C, AOCN
University of Arizona Cancer Center
Lalan S. Wilfong, MD
Texas Oncology/The US Oncology Network
Rena Kass, MD
Penn State Hershey Medical Center
Lillie D. Shockney, RN, BS, MAS, HON-ONN-CG
Co-Founder, AONN+; Editor, JONS; University Distinguished Service Professor of Breast Cancer, Professor of Surgery, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine; Co-Developer, Work Stride-Managing Cancer at Work, Johns Hopkins Healthcare Solutions
Mary C. Politi, PhD
Washington University in St. Louis
Reshma Jagsi, MD, DPhil
University of Michigan
Thomas W. LeBlanc, MD
Duke University School of Medicine
Ellen Sonet
Jamie L. Studts, PhD
University of Colorado Cancer Center
Andrea Hutton
Metastatic Breast Cancer Alliance
Elana Plotkin
Association of Community Cancer Centers
Lorna Lucas, MS
Association of Community Cancer Centers

Background: Patients who engage in decision-making are more likely to experience confidence and satisfaction in treatment decisions and trust in clinicians. Low health literacy can impact decision-making and is associated with greater decisional conflict and diminished understanding of key treatment information. The Association of Community Cancer Centers (ACCC) conducted a survey to explore multidisciplinary team attitudes and practices around shared decision-making (SDM) and health literacy. We also explored the critical role navigators and social workers play in supporting patients with decisions and attending to health literacy barriers.

Objective: Understand stakeholders’ attitudes, challenges, and effective practices for engaging patients with cancer through SDM. Identify resources, education, and tools needed for oncology nurse navigators, social workers, patient navigators, and financial navigators to support patients and caregivers through SDM.

Methods: ACCC convened a steering committee of multidisciplinary specialists, professional associations, and advocacy representatives to guide this research. The survey included 26 mostly closed-ended questions and was open to multidisciplinary cancer programs from 10/29/19 to 2/20/20. Of 443 survey respondents, 141 indicated they serve in a navigation role (62% social workers, 20% oncology nurse navigators, 11% financial counselors/navigators, 8% patient navigators). Exploratory analysis was performed on this data set of 141 respondents.

Results: Ninety-nine percent of the 141 respondents reported that their cancer programs ask patients to discuss quality-of-life priorities, and 88% of respondents either sometimes or always engage patients in conversations about treatment decision-making. Respondents stated that additional nurse navigator/social worker follow-up is a common strategy to support patients with low health literacy (78%), patients with metastatic disease (69%), and patients older than 65 years (62%). The most frequently cited perceived barriers to engaging in SDM were not having adequate training (46%) or being unfamiliar with the core concepts of SDM (37%), as well as patients feeling overwhelmed (51%) and having limited health literacy (46%). Most respondents have access to training in cultural sensitivity (66%) and having difficult conversations (60%), but only 17% have access to basic training about SDM. Only 10% indicated that lack of time was a barrier to engaging in SDM. Fewer than half of nurse navigator respondents (45%, n = 23) reported using patient decision aids to support SDM.

Conclusion: SDM is commonly accepted as essential to patient engagement, but clarity in terminology and prioritizing formal integration of SDM into practice is limited. Navigation is an important component of successful implementation of SDM processes. Strategies to improve integration of SDM into practice could include: (1) educational initiatives and tools to overcome barriers to SDM, including SDM training and patient decision aids; (2) initiatives to address health literacy as it relates to patient and caregiver engagement in decision-making; (3) psychosocial support for patients whose emotional upset is a barrier to SDM; and (4) healthcare policies that encourage and incentivize care team members to engage in SDM. Future analyses will require concurrent assessment of patient, caregiver, healthcare professional, and administrator perspectives.

Note: Funding for this project was provided by Pfizer Oncology.

Related Articles
JONS Editor-in-Chief: Passing the Baton
Lillie D. Shockney, RN, BS, MAS, HON-ONN-CG
June 2023 Vol 14, No 6
Dear Navigators, Social Workers, Administrators, and Clinical Staff, With this letter, I want to share some news with you.
National Nurses Month: Celebrating the Impact of Nurses
Lillie D. Shockney, RN, BS, MAS, HON-ONN-CG
May 2023 Vol 14, No 5
All day, every day, nurses make all the difference in delivering high-quality care to those who need it the most. On behalf of all of us at AONN+, I want to recognize the nurses in our community for their invaluable contributions to healthcare.
Our Health History Is in the Stories We Tell Within Black and Brown Families
Maimah Karmo
May 2023 Vol 14, No 5

With National Black Family Cancer Awareness Week (June 15-21, 2023) on the horizon, it is paramount to acknowledge the pivotal role that nurse navigators play in educating and empowering patients and their loved ones—to include fostering candid and transparent conversations about family health history, knowing our bodies, risk reduction, and proactive cancer screenings. As a breast cancer survivor and founder of the Tigerlily Foundation, I am a testament to the profound, lifesaving impact of these conversations. My mother was a nurse, and I often say that she gave me life and saved my life. Here’s how.

Last modified: August 10, 2023

Subscribe Today!

To sign up for our print publication or e-newsletter, please enter your contact information below.

I'd like to receive:

  • First Name *
    Last Name *
    Profession or Role
    Primary Specialty or Disease State